Skip Nav

A Christmas Carol Critical Essays

Suggested Essay Topics

❶In stave three Dickens describes the Market Place and the poor part of town:

Logging out…

From the SparkNotes Blog
Popular Topics
How to cite this page

An employee of Fezziwig asks Scrooge if he can still work. Scrooge asks him his pay, he replies five shillings, Scrooge says that he can work for four.

When Marley was dying, the housekeeper calls for Scrooge to come. He says it is only quarter-to-five, he will come at seven, when he closes the business. Scrooge gets there just in time and Marley says that it is not too late to right his wrong doings, and to save himself. I feel anger towards Scrooge, no sympathy to him, because his only friend was dead.

Alice is called Bella in the book and also Bella in the modern version. Alice was Scrooges ex-fianci?? Alice looking after people in a workhouse, an old woman thanks her for being so nice, Alice us a woman which helps, unlike Scrooge, a man that takes. They are so different. This scene was added, I suppose to add humour, where, Scrooge asks his housekeeper what day it is. She thinks that he has gone mad. Scrooge gives her a guinea, which is twenty-one shillings for a Christmas present and raises her salary from two shillings to ten.

At the Christmas dinner with Scrooge and his nephew, Scrooge asks his nephew and his wife to forgive him. They do, and Scrooge joins in dancing.

As before, Scrooge again, walks past the blind boy with the dog. He gives the boy some money, and pats the dog, that now likes him. This is when Scrooge changes from mean to generous; he sees his wrong doings. The special effects with these media pieces are very different but you have to take into account that there are a number of years difference between the two pieces and, you have to take into account what would appeal to the audience of that time and the interpretations of that special effect.

Special effects from the version are very basic. It catches your eye and attracts you to the film. The voice over of Marley calling Scrooge as he walks up the stairs, the same thing is repeated when Scrooge is eating gruel. Chains are heard and the door flings open. The spirits, who are bound with chains, try to help a woman with a child. Its too late to right their wrong doings.

The spirit appears and floats towards the bed. The bedroom scene of Scrooge and the ghost fades into the scene where Scrooge used to live. Alice walks through the shadow of Scrooge. This special effect is repeated four times, where the scene fades into an hour-glass in a tunnel, then fades out into the next scene. Pawnbrokers fade into the graveyard scene, and finally, the voice over at the end, which is the epilogue of the book.

Marley makes his entrance through the fridge. Another effect is where the final spirit is floating away, Scrooge has to run to keep up with him. This is the opposite of what special effects are meant to do. It would have been better if we had watched the film in black and white instead of colour because the colour picture made the special effects look basic and used in a way.

There are many parts of humour in both the versions, mainly when Scrooge turns from mean to generous, in the version, where Scrooge dances at the end and when Jo the pawnbroker was mad.

This is also humorous. In the modern version, the humour is the same, the change between mean to generous and the way that Scrooge scares people. The 19th century, due to rapidly expanding industrialization, saw an appalling rise in poverty, and the exploitation of poor children, who were often forced to work in the rapidly expanding factories. Today this is happening all over the world and especially in developing countries.

Charles Dickens wrote this novel at the beginning of the Hungry Forties, this being a period of intense suffering for the working classes. Dickens sought to make his comfortable middle-class readers aware of the appalling poverty around them. This can contrast to what is going on today in our society, poverty exists everywhere and it is also important to be aware and then assist in any way possible to then help those who need it.

These words come back to haunt Scrooge several times in the course of the text and the inhumanity of his question is emphasised by his increased discomfort when confronted with his words.

He was reacting to the fact that even in Christmas was beginning to lose its true meaning with the introduction of Christmas trees, greeting cards and presents.

It is in essence a Christian fable with the message that the meek, such as Bob Cratchit, are truly worthy and that charity is a noble cause. In the 21st century we may be less religious than the Victorians of 19th-century England, but we still recognise the message and may similarly react to the commercialisation of Christmas. The audience from the 21st century may play down the religious elements of the story and highlight the humanitarian aspect, but the gist is still the same.

A Christmas Carol allows 21st centuries readers to be able to establish a clear connection to the times that they are living in to the times that Dickens was writing in. It is clear the true happiness comes from good deeds and money does not bring a wealth of happiness. The true meaning of Christmas is also shown, but it is also clear that it was materialised, just as it is today. A Christmas Carol has relevance to the circumstances of the society today and is not only just a cliched moral fable.

Home Essays A Christmas Carol.

Navigate Guide

Main Topics

Privacy Policy

In A Christmas Carol, an allegory of spiritual values versus material ones, Charles Dickens shows Scrooge having to learn the lesson of the spirit of Christmas, facing the reality of his own.

Privacy FAQs

Free A Christmas Carol papers, essays, and research papers.

About Our Ads

A Christmas Carol, although it is of a different time period still today teaches valuable lessons. In the story, Ebeneezer Scrooge begins by having no feelings for anything or anybody. In the end, he changes from his gloomy, dark self. Charles Dickens expresses through a Christmas Carol that /5(10). Essays and criticism on Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol - A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens.

Cookie Info

A Christmas Carol Essay. Charles Dickens's A Christmas Carol is a morality tale of a selfish and bitter Ebenezer Scrooge and his visits from 3 spirits representing his past, present and future, bringing him into a complete change of character and reconciliation for his wrongs. Starting an essay on Charles Dickens's A Christmas Carol? Organize your thoughts and more at our handy-dandy Shmoop Writing Lab.